We already had a post regarding the mean reverting behaviour of Volatility, now it`s time to make some money using this information.
The VIX volatility index on the chart above looks like an easy to trade instrument, just buy when it is around 10 and sell when it has doubled, tripled, quadrupled…
But unfortunately life is not that easy, VIX is just an index and you will not be able to buy or sell it. You might try to trade volatility using options, but there is a better plan to make money on this wonderful asset class, the VXX, BRCL BK IPTH S&P 500 VIX SH FTRS ETN.
VXX – the perfect money printing machine
The VXX is an ETN which tries to follow the vix on a short timescale buy having exposure to the first 2 VIX futures contracts. But like with commodities, where the further out contracts cost more money (a risk premium), this leads to severe losses in the long run. You buy expensive (far out) and then the premium melts away. This is a general problem of all ETFs which try to follow a physical market, and will be my edge in making money.
Like VXX also USO and UNG (physical Gas and Oil ETFs) are doomed to go to ZERO in the long run. Only reverse splits could hold them from reaching this target by now.
I am not up to track or trade the VIX on a short term basis, I am more interested in making money due to this structural bug build in in the methodology used to track the VIX. So for me VXX (similar to USO and UNG) is a long term short investment.
Having a look at a long term comparison between VIX and VXX will surely give you the same idea:
note the logarithmic scale for VXX!
No risk, no return
The above chart gives you the returns distribution of VXX over 5 -50 -250 trading days. On a yearly basis you hardly had any positive return, and the median loss (=win for shorties) would have been 47%. Even the 2-month 50 day return has got a median of -17%, with only a 20% chance of a positive return over this period of time. So the odds are clearly with you, the longer you hold, the more you gain.
On the other side, things are never that easy as they seem, it would be suicide just to invest all your money in a VXX short trade.
Even when the odds are on your side, you will get a problem with risk. While VIX has the nasty tendency to quadruple from time to time, it even went from 10 to 90 in 2008, VXX as a short term tracker of VIX could also behave like this. Since 2013 when the instrument came into existence, there has been several incidents when VXX at least doubled on the short term. That would be the incident when your broker gives you a markin call or closes your position at the worst possible moment. To be on the safe side don`t invest more than 25% of your account into a VXX short trade!
VXX, USO, UNG – my short list for short trades
Your edge in trading VXX is not the trend down, but this fundamental problem in tracking the VIX index using the next two months futures contracts. The same problem which brings down the united states oil and gas fund USO und UNG. Like the VXX the returns distribution (50 and 250 days) gives a clear indication to trade these instruments only on the short side.
These returns distributions, caused by the the fundamental tracking problem of a futures market, make VXX, USO and UNG my private money printing machines. VXX is a clear “short and hold”, USO and UNG are a “short when strong” opportunity.
Research pays off!